I have spent much of my career studying environmental disasters, assessing the risks of industrial development, and working with communities forced to live with the consequences of decisions they had little power to influence.
One of the most important lessons from that work is that environmental disasters rarely occur because we lacked the scientific knowledge to prevent them. More often, they occur because those with the power to act ignored the evidence, prioritized economic interests, and/or failed to listen to the people in harm’s way.
Congress is now dangerously close to institutionalizing those failures.
On Thursday, the Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), legislation that would substantially weaken some of America’s most consequential environmental laws. Fourteen Democrats joined Republicans in supporting its passage.
Marketed to Democrats as a clean energy initiative and to Republicans as a means of accelerating fossil fuel development, the legislation threatens the National Environmental Policy Act, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and National Historic Preservation Act.
A letter signed by 118 environmental and energy law scholars identified twelve particularly destructive provisions and urged Congress to reject them.
The Senate passed it anyway.
On Tuesday’s Barometer Report, I interviewed Alejandro E. Camacho, a UCLA environmental law professor who organized the scholars’ letter.
Among his greatest concerns was Section 1401, which would establish what critics call forever permits, severely restricting the government’s ability to modify or revoke previously issued permits.
Even with exceptions introduced during negotiations, the legislation creates substantial obstacles to intervening when new scientific evidence reveals environmental or public health risks. Gradually accumulating contamination, elevated cancer risks, and other long-term consequences may not meet the exception’s stringent requirements.
Science is a process of discovery. Our understanding of chemical toxicity, groundwater contamination, ecosystem dynamics and human health evolves constantly.
Government policy must retain the capacity to respond accordingly.
BAAJA would simultaneously restrict environmental assessments, limit consideration of emerging research, shorten opportunities for legal challenges and severely constrain courts’ ability to halt construction when environmental review requirements have been violated.
As Camacho explained during our interview, this creates, in many circumstances, a right without a remedy.
What good is winning a lawsuit to protect a wetland after the wetland has been destroyed?
The National Congress of American Indians has warned that BAAJA undermines tribal sovereignty, threatens sacred places and conflicts with federal treaty and trust obligations.
Having worked extensively with Indigenous communities in coastal Louisiana, I’ve witnessed the devastating consequences of industrial development imposed upon communities without meaningful participation or consent.
Oil and gas infrastructure contributed to the fragmentation of Louisiana’s coastal wetlands, increasing the vulnerability of communities that had occupied those lands for generations.
BAAJA risks perpetuating that injustice nationwide.
Meanwhile, Section 1402 creates extraordinary financial protections for developers, allowing qualifying companies to pursue taxpayer-funded compensation that could reach the full projected cost of construction.
Corporations could receive enormous payouts while communities struggle to secure meaningful remedies for environmental destruction.
That isn’t accountability. It’s the public underwriting corporate risk.
A clean energy bill that fuels fossil fuels
America desperately needs modernized electricity transmission infrastructure and rapid decarbonization.
But BAAJA does not limit its permitting advantages to renewable energy.
It facilitates natural gas infrastructure, mining, and other industrial development, including infrastructure supporting the proliferation of energy-intensive AI data centers.
Even the Natural Resources Defense Council, which recognizes the legislation’s valuable transmission reforms, has warned about locking in preferential treatment for fossil fuel projects and potentially exposing taxpayers to billions in corporate compensation.
The objective of climate policy is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, not simply to build more energy infrastructure.
We cannot bulldoze our way toward climate justice by sacrificing environmental protections, Indigenous rights and public health.
The House can still stop this
The legislation now returns to the House of Representatives as H.R. 2347.
More than 140 environmental and conservation organizations have opposed this legislative effort. Legal scholars, tribal leaders and public health advocates have sounded the alarm.
Congress can pursue meaningful transmission reform without dismantling the safeguards that protect our communities.
Contact your House representative today. Tell them to vote NO on BAAJA.
Call the congressional switchboard at (202) 224-3121 or find your representative and contact their office directly.
Demand legislation that accelerates decarbonization without sacrificing scientific integrity, public participation, environmental justice or corporate accountability.
It took generations of scientists, activists, Indigenous leaders and ordinary Americans fighting for their communities to establish these protections.
We cannot afford to surrender them now.


I called the switchboard and they disconnected me. Attempt #2
Thanks for your work, Rebekah. Happy to talk again (with less Tech problems!) if you think it’ll be helpful.